One Must Be Sacrificed

A horror short story by Matt Holland

They hammered on the door again. Inside all of our hearts turned to ice.

“One of us needs to go out there,” Kevin said. He cast his eye around the room, more or less saying that it was going to be one of us going outside this time – not him. It was never him. Kevin loved playing the leader right up until he actually had to do something.

I don’t know why we followed him around everywhere, but in a situation as dire as this you had to follow somebody.

“I’m not going out there,” said Stephanie. “You can’t make me.”

“Look, they’re out there right now and they’re not going away until one of us goes out there,” James said. Sweet, level-headed James. As if it was that easy. “Nobody wants to do it, but there’s no other way.”

A silence settled over us as we huddled around the fire. Somebody had to say something. But we all knew, whoever spoke next had to be the dumbest person alive.

“Should we draw straws?” I asked.

“There’s no time for that,” Kevin said, probably because drawing straws gave him an equal chance of having to go outside.

“No, that’s a good idea,” James said. “Does anyone have any straws?”

“Because that was one thing I made sure to pack before I left wasn’t it? Asthma inhaler? Who needs that shit? I’ll be alright so long as I have my fucking straws,” Kevin looked James up and down. “You stupid arsehole.”

“I have straws,” Stephanie said.

“Why?”

“Does it matter?” Stephanie took out a packet of paper drinking straws. Those weren’t the straws I had in mind but I didn’t want to say anything. I let her count out enough straws for each of us and hold them out. “Everyone take one.”

“This isn’t fair,” Kevin said, but he took a straw same as the rest of us.

He sighed with relief when he saw his. It was the longest one. Stephanie had the next longest, then James, then Barry and…

“Oh no,” I said. There was nobody else. I had the short straw.

“You’ve got to go. You suggested it,” Kevin said a hint of a smile creeping up his face.

“But I don’t want to,” I said.

“You have to,” Stepanie said. “I’m really sorry.”

My heart pounded in my chest. This couldn’t be happening. It was a bad dream. 

“Please. There’s got to be another way.”

“There isn’t,” James said.

“This was your idea after all,” Kevin said, happy now that he was the one who didn’t have to go outside.

They banged on the door again, louder this time. My stomach dropped. They were outside with only a few inches of wood between us. This was the last minute. Somebody would swoop in and save me. Somebody had to.

Please.

“Go on then,” Kevin said.

I didn’t say goodbye. I didn’t need to.

I took a deep breath, squared my jaw, and took the money outside to pay the pizza guy.

To be fair to him, he’d been waiting outside for a while – and it was bloody cold out there.

—- Matt Holland 29/12/2018

This story has been brought to you with the help of Suzie Hunt and my patrons. If you want to get your name on a future article or story, consider donating to my patreon yourself to earn some cool rewards and some slightly less cool eternal gratitude.  I also have novels for sale here. If you have any questions or comments about this piece, tweet them to me or forever hold your peace.

Or return to the main site here for more fun stuff.

 

Liked it? Take a second to support gallaetha_matt on Patreon!